Dana, the Hindu and Buddhist Ideal of Sharing
by Nitin Kumar
Monday 1 February 2010
HINDU AND BUDDHIST IDEAL OF SHARING
- Krishna and His Friends Enjoy the Meal
Fielding Hall, a British official in nineteenth-century Burma, once asked for a bill at what he had taken to be a village restaurant, and found that he had been fed as a guest in a private house. Little did he know that the simple-minded folk were just practicing one of Buddhism’s fundamental ethical imperatives - the gesture of unconditioned giving.
Indeed, the primary activity which a Buddhist learns to develop is unselfish sharing, which forms a basis for further moral and spiritual development. If the key to any religion is held in its stories, Buddhist literature, abounding in such narratives, gives ample evidence of the high esteem this particular trait is held in.
Thus says the ancient Buddhist Canon:
’Like a jar of water, when overturned, empties all its contents, never to receive them back, thus should one give away without regard to money, fame, one’s progeny, or even our own body to anybody who approaches us with a wish list.’ (Introduction to Jataka)
Throughout the Jataka Stories, the first injunction when any discourse is delivered is to give donations to the poor, food to guests and support and honor to holy men. In Hinduism too, the gift of food is considered especially virtuous because:
’Life is sustained by food and food is life, thus, to give food to others is like giving life to them.’ (Mahabharata: 13.63.26)
The hospitality has to be all embracing, and the guest, whoever she or he may be, has to be welcomed with open arms:
Even if the lowliest of the low arrives as a guest, the householder should welcome him. (Mahabharata: 14.92)
In the timeless text, The Bhagavata Purana, an instructive episode is narrated where Krishna, playing with his famished friends, is addressed thus by the latter:
"O Krishna, like you have annihilated mighty demons tormenting us, so also save us from these pangs of hunger."
Krishna, ever the fulfiller of his devotees’ needs, answered:
"Go to the nearby hall where learned Brahmins are performing a great ritual to attain heaven. Tell them that you have been sent by me and request them to give you some cooked rice."
Obeying the instructions, the young lads went over to the hermitage, prostrated them before the priests and requested:
"Venerable saints, we are the servants of Lord Krishna who is playing with us nearby. He is now hungry and has asked us to seek food from you - the true knowers of Dharma."
Ignorantly engaged in toilsome rituals and acts of everyday life, yet vainglorious of their textual wisdom, the Brahmins, though they heard the solicitations of the lord, who out of Grace send his friends for food to them, did not heed to their needs.
Disappointed, they reported what had happened to Krishna, who laughing out aloud said:
"Now go to the affectionate wives of these Brahmins and ask the same of them. They will definitely feed you to your heart’s content."
To those pious women the lads respectfully submitted:
"Salutations to you virtuous ladies. We have been deputed by Lord Krishna to seek food for our hungry group."
No sooner had they heard that the lord was so near, giving them an opportunity to fulfill his and his followers’ hunger, the Brahmin women immediately gathered sumptuous food in large vessels and like rivers rushing towards the ocean, eagerly reached out to Krishna welcoming him through the gates of their eyes, establishing him into their hearts.
Later, the saints, remembering their uncharitable behavior, lamented: "Alas, we have disregarded the lord who has taken the form of a human being. All our knowledge, vows and pure birth are useless, because due to pride, we were unable to recognize the divinity in humanity." (Bhagavata Purana: 10.23)
This simple narrative has a profound implication, alerting us to the realization that if we are lucky enough to have somebody needful at our threshold, it is perhaps god himself who has condescended to bless us. Thus is it said:
’With a guest come all the gods. If a guest is honored, so are they; if he goes away disappointed, they are disappointed too.’ (Mahabharata: 14.92)
- Krishna Washes
the Feet of His Guest Sudama
Significantly, the word used for guest in Sanskrit is ’atithi’, ’tithi’ meaning date and the prefix ’a’ negating it. Therefore, one who arrives unexpectedly without prior date or appointment is the guest extolled here:
The Bhagavad Gita calls such an unsolicited opportunity to perform one’s duty (made available by chance and not effort), a direct gateway to heaven (2.32).
Our experience of the world is one of interdependence, and we do not exist as isolated elements but are related to each other as many strands of a fabric. Hindu and Buddhist texts provide structures through which trustworthy views of this experience can be developed, recognizing that such interdependence is not just of the nature of the body, but at a deeper level, of human social life. Such an outlook involves not only accommodation, but also slowly but steadily cultivates in us the ideal of renunciation, defined as the abandonment of material things over to someone else, and which is a necessary first step towards Nirvana or Moksha.
In fact, the quality of giving is one of the virtues perfected over numerous lifetimes by Buddha in his bodhisattva phase, before the final culmination into Nirvana, after he has given up all attachment. This is symbolized by the sacrifice of his own body when he has nothing else to offer an unexpected guest. In the Jataka Tale entitled ’Shasha Jataka’ (story no. 316), the Buddha is born as a rabbit, and unable to present any other food to a Brahmin come home, roasted himself in a fire. Later of course, it turns out that his guest is but god testing his resolve.
A similar message is given by the story of King Shibi in the Jataka Mala, who having given away all his wealth, was still moved enough by small insects hovering around him, and inflicted several wounds on his body to feed the mosquitoes. In another narrative from the same text, the bodhisattva throws himself in front of a hungry tigress, who, otherwise, was on the verge of consuming her own cubs. This is however not the only instance of the Buddha-To-Be sacrificing his physical body partly or fully and numerous tales abound in Buddhist Canonical literature illustrating this theme.
- Buddha Discourses to Ananda
The Buddha explained that intense compassion for mankind and the love of Bodhi (spiritual awakening), sustain and inspire a bodhisattva towards heroism, just as worldly men are inclined to enjoy sensual pleasures even when their bodies are burning with fever.
Before being so advanced spiritually so as to make these supreme sacrifices, the bodhisattva, in many of his live prior to Buddhahood, continued to cultivate the perfection (paramita) of Dana, experiencing greater pleasure in giving than those receiving it. When the action of giving is thus internalized in so profound a manner, becoming almost one’s second, nay primary nature, Krishna compares such unselfish magnanimity with the inspiring life of trees:
"Have a look at these great blessed trees, who live only for the welfare of others, themselves facing the severity of stormy winds, heavy showers, heat and snow, all the while protecting us from them. The birth of trees is the most blessed in the world, as they contribute unreservedly to the well being of all creatures. Just as no needy person ever returns disappointed from the house of a benevolent individual, similarly do these trees do for those who approach them for shelter. All of their many parts - leaves, flowers, fruits, shadow, roots, bark, wood and fragrance, are useful to others. Indeed, there are many who live on this earth, but the birth of only those is successful, who, as far as possible, through their wealth, intellect, speech and lives, engage in acts conducive to the welfare of others." (Bhagavata Purana 10.22.32 - 35)
The Mahabharata asks us to embrace even one perceived to be an enemy, should he arrive at our threshold: ’Should even one’s enemy arrive at the doorstep, he should be attended upon with respect. A tree does not withdraw its cooling shade even from the one who has come to cut it.’ (12.146.5)
It calls the bodhisattva as one without attachment to specific individuals, but who perceives all creatures with benevolence like a father his son. There is a beautiful passage in the Bhagavata Purana complementing the above ideal:
Man has right over only that much wealth as is enough to satisfy his hunger. He who lays a claim on the surplus is a thief and deserves punishment. One should look upon beasts, camels, donkeys, monkeys, rats, creatures who crawl on the earth (serpents etc), birds and mosquitoes like one’s own sons, and these should therefore not be driven out of the house or fields if they enter and begin to eat, for what indeed is the difference between them and his sons? (7.14.8 - 9)
This is perhaps akin to Mahatma Gandhi’s concept of trusteeship, where anyone with wealth in excess of his basic needs realizes himself to be only a trustee of his prosperity, and who understands that his continuation in the office depends only on his overseeing that it is judiciously shared amongst all shareholders.
The Bodhichariyavatara takes even a deeper perspective, laying special emphasis on placing oneself in the position of others (par-atma-parivartana), in order to promote selflessness (an-atman) and compassion (karuna): ’Whoever wishes for salvation should practice the supreme mystery - the exchanging of himself and the other.’ (8.120)
Governed by this high ideal, such selfless giving does not expect anything in return. It is perhaps only a way of saying thanks to the one god who has created us all in equality. According to Krishna, a sharing which wants its price is but mere shop keeping:
"Those who love only when loved, their whole enterprise is based on selfishness. It is only giving and taking. It is nor a joining of hearts, neither Dharma. This love is just for self-interest and nothing else. Those who show affection to even those who do not reciprocate their love are like parents, full of karuna. Here lies pure and spotless Dharma." (Bhagavata Purana 10.32.17 - 18)
What all these instances suggest is that the sense of giving is not mere alms giving or charity, but a sharing of what one has been given, in the awareness that one’s life is connected with other beings. Hospitality is one such expression of this realization, beyond mere ritual etiquette:
Even if he diligently studies the Veda day after day, but fails to welcome his guest, then the life of such a Brahmin is in vain. If one wishes to reap the fruits of ritual rites, then let one attend upon a guest who arrives hungry and thirsty at his doorstep with food and respect. (Mahabharata: 14.92)
Equally important with the act of giving is the attitude, the feeling with which the offerings are made. The word used for ritual giving in Sanskrit, is ’Dana’, whose meanings are sharing, communicating, imparting, paying back (as a debt), restoring, and adding to. The ancient tradition of holistic healing, Ayurveda, speaks of four kinds of defects which can afflict cooked food:
1). The Defect of Time (Kala Dosha) - The food that has been kept for too long.
2). The Defect of Flavor (Rasa Dosha) - That which has lost its taste.
3). The Defect of Company (Samsarga Dosha): Touched by unclean hands, or in which some insect has fallen
4). The Defect of Sentiment (Bhava Dosha) - That which is offered with ill grace or without affection. Such a food is not food, it is poison and the worst out of the four categories.
In Buddhist Ethics too, the overall focus is on the psychological aspects of an action, that is, on the intention or volition (chetana) behind it. The Kathavatthu of the Pali Canon holds that Dana is not only the act of giving and gift itself, but the mental state of liberality as well. Thus it is not the absolute size of the gift that is noteworthy, but its proportion out of one’s own stock, that characterizes the ’abundance’ of a gift.
- King Rantideva Worships God Come in the Form of Man and His Dogs
The story of King Rantideva illustrates one such episode, where this monarch, having given away all his wealth, fell on to days of hardship, and had to go even without water for a stretch of forty-eight days. However, on the morning of the forty-ninth, he managed to get a meal of rice cooked in butter. As soon as the family sat down to break their fast, a Brahmin guest arrived, and the family, visualizing god in everything, received him with reverence and gave him a share. Before they could partake of the remaining food, another stranger, this time a Shudra, knocked at their door. He was also lovingly given a portion of the meal. After him came a stranger with his dogs, requesting to be fed along with his hounds. The householder dutifully bowed before the god arrived in the form of the dogs and their master. Lastly, only water having remained, that too was asked by for by a parched Chandala (keeper of funeral grounds). King Rantideva, observing the latter’s plight said: I do not seek from The Almighty Lord any kind of special powers. I would rather prefer to dwell in all beings and undergo their sufferings myself, relieving them of their miseries. By offering water to this unfortunate person, ally my thirst, exhaustion, distress and hunger have been quenched." Later, the family was blessed with a vision (darshan) of the lord himself, who extolled their sacrifice, which consisted of all they possessed.
References and Further Reading
Badrinath, Chaturvedi. The Mahabharata An Inquiry in the Human Condition New Delhi, 2006.
Dayal, Har. The Bodhisattva Doctrine in Buddhist Sanskrit Literature Delhi, 1999.
Findly, Ellison Banks. Dana: Giving and Getting in Pali Buddhism Delhi, 2003.
Kausalyayan, Bhadant Anand (tr.) Jatak (Hindi Translation in Six Volumes): Allahabad, 1995.
Keown, Damien. Oxford Dictionary of Buddhism: Oxford, 2003.
Mishra, Dr. Jagdishchandra (tr.) Jatakmala (Sanskrit Text with Hindi Translation): Varanasi, 1989.
Narain, Vijay. Jatakmala or The Pearls Of Indian Wisdom Delhi, 2006.
Ranganathananda, Swami. Universal Message of the Bhagavad Gita (3 Vols.) (2nd ed.): Kolkata, 2003.
Saraswati, Swami Akhandananda (tr). Shrimad Bhagavata Purana (2 Volumes): Gorakhpur, 2004.
Sharma, Parmananda. Santideva’s Bodhicharyavatara (Original Sanskrit Text with English -Translation and Exposition Based on Prajnakarmati’s Panjika) New Delhi, 2001.
Shaw, Sarah (tr.) The Jatakas Birth Stories of the Bodhisatta New Delhi, 2006.
Tagare, G.V. (tr). The Bhagavata Purana (5 Volumes (Annotated)) Delhi, 2002.
This article by Nitin Kumar.
Copyright © 2008, ExoticIndiaArt
Buddhachannel Diffusion -www.buddhachannel.tv